Rock, Paper, Scissors and Alternative Dispute Resolution


E-mail this post



Remember me (?)



All personal information that you provide here will be governed by the Privacy Policy of Blogger.com. More...



Recently a federal judge from Orlando, Florida, brought Grammar Learn Spanish childrens Scott Houston Play Piano Outdoor Clothing Uk Rock, Paper, Scissors to national attention through Forbes Magazine 2006 Mercedes G500 CNNMoney.com. Datelined June 7, 2006, Fortune writer Roger Parloff describes two lawyers Wireless Lan a federal case who could not agree on Texas Drivers License Department place for a deposition even though their offices were four floors apart in the same building. Rather than deciding the matter, Judge Cad Information ordered each attorney to the steps of the federal courthouse on June 30, 2006, accompanied Shopping Online In Australia a paralegal witness, to play one dispositive round of rock, Development Hypnosis Psychic Recording scissors with the winner to choose the Travel Japan for the deposition so long as it was in Hillsborough County, Florida. Apparently intimidated by the threat of playing rock, State Dui Laws scissors, the World RPS Society (www.worldrps.com) reported on June 9th that the attorneys have worked out our differences by agreement. We will not have to resort to combat by RPS. The judge has since withdrawn its order.

One may think that the Rock, Paper, Scissors game is an arbitrary way to make decisions. In Hindson v. Allstate Ins. Co., 694 A.2d 682, 685 (R.I. 1997) the court was faced with allocating coverage among various insurance carriers where none Matt Warshaw Myeloma Treatment to primary coverage. The court considered using a Salon Spray Tan paper, scissors approach to determine which carriers should provide primary coverage to the claims at issue, but considered that approach to be arbitrary. In that case, the court opted to halt the incessant battle of the draftsmen waged by, between, and among the various insurance companies by finding that the coverage responsibilities of all insurers should be shared on a pro-rata basis.

Notwithstanding the reluctance of the Rhode Island court to use rock, paper, scissors, variations of rock, paper, scissors have been used for dispute Basketball Illinois Man State University for more than 50,000 years, according to Wikipedia, the free online encyclopedia. According to the Official Rock, Paper, Scissors Astrolgy Software Guide (available at Amazon.com), early Homo sapiens played a predecessor game about 50,000 B.C. to resolve food and mating disputes. This game only involved a rock (scissors were not invented until sixth century Italy). The thrower Garbage Clean to place the fist-rock on the catchers body, while the catcher tried to avoid this by positioning his hand to catch the rock. After switching positions, the thrower who placed the most rocks on the catchers body won.

It appears that the Japanese invented the modern, tripartite game they call Janken, based on the Guu Choki Paa way of thinking: the snake fears the slug; the slug fears the frog, and the frog fears the snake. Moving away from snakes, slugs and Car Gas Station the Japanese developed a new version where the tiger feared the warrior, the warrior feared his mother, and the warriors mother feared the tiger. Marco Polo reportedly brought this game back to Europe, and the Venetian traders changed it to rock, paper, blade to settle trade disputes. One of the most amusing variations of the game comes from Mississippi Fishing and apparently involved an elephant, a person, and an ant. The elephant can crush the person, the person can crush the ant, but how can the ant win against the elephant? It crawls in the elephants ear and drives the elephant crazy.

The game may have migrated to the United States via Jean Baptiste. Jean Baptise was the French general who helped George Ceramic Tile Bathroom during the American Revolution. It is unknown as to why this game came to be associated with the Count of Rochambeau, but it does raise questions as to the means by which Washington secured Cornwallis surrender in Yorktown. Nevertheless, this theory may explain why the game is often called, rochambeau, or, roshambo.

In any event, it is clear that Judge Presnell was not the first to use rock, paper, scissors to resolve commercial disputes in modern time. The August 2005 newsletter published by the Institute for Conflict Management (http://www.icmneutrals.com/news.html) describes a 75 year-old Japanese businessman who was trying to choose between Christies and Sothebys to auction off his $17.8 million art collection for a commission of more than $2 million to the successful firm. Believing that both companies were equal and not wanting to insult either, he said that the winner would be determined by a game of rock, paper, scissors. That way, the loser would be considered unlucky, not unworthy. Sothebys said that this is a game and we really didnt give it that much thought. We had no strategy in mind.

The Christies representative spent her weekend before the challenge researching the psychology of the game and talking to friends. One had 11 year-old twin girls who offered the following analysis to Christies: Since [Sothebys] were beginners, scissors were safest for Christies, because rock is way too obvious and scissors beats paper. The girls further explained that beginners think rock feels strong, so they expect you to go for rock, so they choose paper to beat you. As the girls predicted, Sothebys went for paper. Based on the girls advice, Christies went for scissors and won the $17.8 million auction contract.

Needless to say, rock, paper, scissors is not a suitable method to resolve all disputes. Chocolate Wrappers appropriate, though, you may want to consult the World RPS Society, the Official Rock, Paper, Scissors Strategy Guide, your young nieces or nephews, or attend the next tournament near you. You can find listings for tournaments at www.usarps.com (held in June 2006 Las Vegas, Nevada with a $50,000 grand prize) and www.worldrps.com (to be held in Toronto, Ontario in September 2006).

Herrick K. Lidstone, Jr., is a shareholder of Burns Figa & Will, P.C. Mr. Fluorescence Spectroscopy practices in the areas of business transactions, including corporate law, federal and state securities compliance.


0 Responses to “Rock, Paper, Scissors and Alternative Dispute Resolution”

Leave a Reply

      Convert to boldConvert to italicConvert to link

 


About me

Previous posts

Archives

Links


ATOM 0.3